4/5/2023 0 Comments I am the captainHere is where a new view of free will is needed. How can genes both control us and allow for free choice? How can the brain produce thought but also be affected by thinking? Instead of working out the problem of free will largely by logical reasoning (which rarely succeeds, since your opponent calls upon the opposite logic), supporters of free will can point to genetics and neuroscience, the very areas that strongly suggest that determinism is at work. The free will camp has been short of data and facts for a long time, but no more. This has created a serious mismatch between experience and theory, because science, after all, is supposed to settle difficult questions with data, experiments, and facts. determinism debate totally academic–in everyday life we all proceed as if our choices and decisions are our own. The average person finds the free will vs. ![]() A generation ago human behavior was largely attributed to genes, although the fashion today is to claim that the brain is the major controller of what we think, say, and do. There is ample proof, on the other hand, that deterministic forces are at work inside us. There is no proof you have a soul, if you are a materialist. On many grounds this anthem to free will can be refuted. ![]() The other leg was saved only after many surgeries, and while he was recovering, Henley was inspired to write his poem, which ended on a triumphant note: "I am the master of my fate, I am the captain of my soul." Henley had grown up in poverty, and when he was 29 one of his legs had to be amputated as a consequence of tuberculosis. The sentiment being expressed is more than empty piousness. Back when schoolchildren regularly read uplifting poetry, there was a famous Victorian poem that affirmed the human birthright of free will.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |